Miss America 2026 winner Cassie Donegan faced online criticism for her pageant makeup but responded with grace, self-love, and a powerful message of individuality.
What should have been a night of celebration for Cassie Donegan, the new Miss America 2026, quickly turned into a storm of online criticism.
The 28-year-old singer from New York was crowned at the Walt Disney Theater in Orlando, Florida on September 7, winning over the judges with her stunning talent and confidence. Along with the crown, she received a $50,000 scholarship and another $3,000 for her talent performance.
But soon after her victory, the conversation shifted online — and not about her win. Instead, critics targeted her makeup look, with one viral post declaring, “Her makeup artist didn’t want her to win.”
From Standing Ovation to Online Criticism
View this post on Instagram
Social media was divided. Some fans argued that “Texas should have won,” while others defended Donegan, praising her talent and calling her beautiful regardless of the makeup debate.
Donegan addressed the criticism in an interview with People, saying:
“I’m just a normal person. No, I don’t want to hear negativity, especially about my appearance. But I respect that the internet is a public space, and no one will ever be everyone’s favorite all the time.”
Embracing Her “Grandma Chic” Style
View this post on Instagram
On stage, Donegan used her moment to share a message of authenticity and individuality. She encouraged people to embrace who they are, whether that means wearing tattoos, piercings, or unique styles that might not appeal to everyone.
View this post on Instagram
She proudly joked that her siblings call her fashion sense “grandma chic”, a label she fully embraces.
“If even one person feels seen or loved through me as Miss America, then I’ve done my job.”
View this post on Instagram
The Miss America Organization showed their support with an Instagram post celebrating her win:
“Miss America 2026, Cassie Donegan! 🗽 #ThereSheIs.”
From Small-Town Girl to Miss America
@missamerica A few words from our new Miss America, @Cassie Donegan! ❤️ #missamerica #fyp #foryoupage
Though she now shines on the national stage, Donegan’s story began in a small town in Virginia. She grew up singing in church before studying Musical Theatre at Belmont University in Nashville.
On her personal website, she describes herself as a “goofball” who loves to laugh, loves fully, and feels lucky to live her dream of performing. She credits her family as her biggest support and says her dogs bring her joy.
Her honesty even extends to her guilty pleasures: sushi and avocados.
Miss America With a Mission
Despite the harsh comments, Donegan is choosing to focus on spreading positivity. She’s using her platform to champion empathy, courage, and self-love, proving that beauty is more than makeup and crowns.
Her journey is a reminder that even in the face of criticism, confidence and kindness shine brightest.
